More Insights
See all
185K+
Websites + Marketplaces Tracked
1M+
Merchants Tracked
1.2M+
of Automated Actions Initiated Monthly
2.4B+
of Data Points Tracked
Loss leaders can seem like a clever move: sell a popular item at a steep discount to attract attention and drive traffic. But for brands, this tactic often comes with serious downsides, especially when you're the one being discounted.In this article, we’ll explore how loss-leader strategies can undermine brand equity, trigger channel conflict, erode pricing power, and complicate relationships with retail partners. And with today’s tariff volatility and supply chain stress, it’s more important than ever to protect your pricing and positioning.
What is a loss leader?
A loss leader is a product that’s sold at a loss — or with extremely slim margins — to attract customers who will ideally purchase other items at full price.Think of it this way: a customer sees a well-known brand’s item marked way down and clicks or walks in. That discounted product becomes the gateway to a bigger transaction. It works well for retailers. But for the brand being discounted, the long-term effects can be damaging.
Loss leaders' impact on brand equity
While deep discounts can increase exposure and short-term sales, they can also dilute your brand. If your premium product is consistently offered at a low price, customers may begin to see it as cheap or commoditized.This shift in perception is hard to reverse. Once a product that regularly retails for $100 is frequently seen online at $50, that lower price becomes the customer’s new reference point. Selling it at full price again becomes a challenge.
Many luxury brands refuse to sell on Amazon or similar platforms to avoid the type of uncontrolled discounting that can tarnish their luxury image. Some brands have taken steps to protect their image and pricing power by stepping away from marketplaces that often rely on loss-leaders. Nike’s decision in 2019 to exit Amazon was a strategic move to preserve its brand integrity and maintain control over its customer experience.
The channel conflict problem
When one major retailer undercuts your product pricing, it puts pressure on every other partner in your distribution chain. Brick-and-mortar stores may lose sales or be forced to match prices, cutting into their margins.The result? Frustrated partners who feel unsupported. This kind of channel conflict can lead to reduced shelf space, fewer in-store promotions, or, in extreme cases, retailers dropping your brand entirely.It is vital to maintain consistent pricing across online and offline channels. If one player disrupts that balance, your entire strategy can suffer.
Loss leaders can cause price erosion and lower customer expectations
Once discount pricing becomes the norm, customers grow accustomed to it. That expectation puts pressure on all your sales channels to match the lower price—or risk losing customers.The baby products industry offers a prime example. Amazon’s deep discounting on diapers in its competition with Diapers.com reset pricing expectations across the market. Competitors had to lower prices just to stay relevant, and margins shrank industry-wide.
Over time, this kind of price compression becomes unsustainable. Your once-premium product is viewed as a value item, and lifting it - and the perception of your brand in the eyes of the consumer - back up is incredibly difficult.This type of price erosion is a serious risk. It can strip a brand of its pricing power not just on the promotional channel but across all sales outlets, compressing margins and even reducing sales in the long run. Both academic analyses and industry reports between 2019 and 2024 underscore that maintaining consistent value perception is key – once consumers internalize a low price point, elevating it later is an uphill battle.
Loss leaders may strain retail relationships
Retailers invest in your brand through merchandising, marketing, and shelf space. But their willingness to support you wanes when they see your product consistently discounted online.They may reduce your presence in stores, cut back on co-marketing, or even switch to competitor brands with tighter pricing control.
Worse, they may ask you to absorb the cost of matching discounts. This leads to lower wholesale pricing or promotional allowances—direct hits to your margins.
PopSockets offers a compelling example. While the brand enjoyed success on Amazon, they were struggling with unauthorized resellers and price discrepancies. Then, Amazon required them to move to a wholesale relationship, which meant Amazon, not PopSockets, could set the price. Rather than give up this control, the brand left Amazon to focus on its own website and alternative partners.
Competing with private labels
Another risk is that your product might be used as a traffic magnet, only to be replaced by a retailer’s in-house brand.Retailers often suggest private-label alternatives alongside your product, usually at an even lower price. You end up doing the marketing work while the sale goes elsewhere. Amazon basics is a compelling example. The list of products now available from Amazon on its own label is growing daily and, in many cases, is severely undercutting brand name products.It’s a subtle but powerful shift in dynamics. The exposure may boost short-term sales, but long-term, it can cannibalize your market share and erode customer loyalty.
Tariffs and supply chain volatility add pressure
With global tariffs and supply chain disruptions driving up costs, most brands can’t afford to take deep losses on heavily discounted products.
When margins are already under pressure, loss-leader pricing can tip the balance from risky to outright damaging. What might once have been an acceptable marketing cost becomes a serious liability.Brands need predictability and margin stability to weather economic uncertainty—and that means being strategic about pricing across all channels.
How can you protect your brand?
While you can’t always stop retailers from using loss-leader tactics, you can take proactive steps to safeguard your brand.
1. Audit and control distribution
Make sure your products aren’t leaking to unauthorized resellers. Clarify distribution agreements and restrict access to known and trusted partners.
2. Implement and enforce pricing policies
Establish a Minimum Advertised Price (MAP) policy and back it with consistent enforcement. Let your partners know you’re serious about pricing integrity.
3. Use Amazon’s brand tools
Leverage Amazon tools like Brand Registry, Transparency, and Project Zero to monitor unauthorized sellers and keep your listings accurate.
4. Strengthen your direct-to-consumer presence
Invest in your own ecommerce channels. A strong DTC strategy gives you pricing control, customer data, and a platform for storytelling.
5. Monitor pricing consistently
Use technology like TrackStreet to track pricing across sellers and platforms. Real-time data gives you leverage in enforcing compliance.
6. Reevaluate partnerships when needed
If a platform or partner consistently undermines your strategy, don’t be afraid to pivot. Nike and PopSockets demonstrated that sometimes protecting the brand means walking away.
Protecting value in a competitive market
Loss-leader pricing can be an effective traffic driver for retailers—but often at the brand’s expense. If you’re not vigilant, your product becomes the bait in someone else’s sales funnel.To maintain control over your brand perception, pricing, and profitability, it’s essential to take an active role in channel management and pricing enforcement.As tariffs fluctuate and costs rise, sustainable pricing practices aren’t just smart—they’re essential. Stay alert, stay strategic, and ensure your brand is positioned for long-term success.
Need help monitoring pricing, enforcing resale policies, or managing online channels? Tools like TrackStreet offer automation and insights to help brands stay in control. Schedule a consultation today!
